
But this one has me most puzzled ...
It looks to me there is a second light source added in this scene
Supermodel

The Wii version under Dolphin. The lighting here other than the brightness is almost identical

I dimmed the ambient somewhat so you can see shading more clearly. There is no specular here ..

Now the real puzzler .. the model3

It's like there is a second light source from the sky.
You can see it in other places too
The guys hand is illuminated on the model3, on supermodel and the Wii version it's not
